Entries in Riddle, Clive (313)

Friday
Jan112019

Two New Milliman White Papers On MSSP Pathways to Success: 

Final Rule Revisions and Data Mining Tactics to Reduce Population Costs

By  Clive Riddle, January 11, 2019

Milliman's Noah Champagne, Charlie Mills, and Jason Karcher published a white paper on January 7th: “Pathways to Success” MSSP final rule: Key revisions to the proposed rule, which was preceded with a paper on January 4th by Kathryn V. Fitch, Adam Laurin, and Michele M. Berrios: “Pathways to Success” MSSP final rule: Faster movement to downside risk increases focus on reducing population costs.

The final rule isn’t a radical departure from the proposed rule, but as Champagne, Mills and Karcher summarize, these are the key changes from the proposed rule:

  • Levels A and B maximum shared savings percentage increased from 25% to 40% while Levels C and D increased from 30% and 40%, respectively, to 50%.
  • Less strict definition of low-revenue ACO: Now ACOs are considered “low revenue" if their historical Medicare Part A and B fee-for-service (FFS) revenues are less than 35% of the total historical expenditures for their assigned Medicare beneficiaries. 
  • High-revenue ACOs currently participating in MSSP Track 1+ will be allowed an exception to renew for one agreement period in Level E of the BASIC track.
  • New, low-revenue ACOs, not experienced with performance-based Medicare ACO initiatives, will be allowed to remain in Level B (one-sided risk) for an additional performance year. 
  • The final rule retains the proposed 3% cap on benchmark increases for risk scores. However, ACOs’ benchmarks will be fully adjusted for changes in the relative risk score when there is a decrease from the baseline year to the performance year instead of applying a 3% reduction cap as originally proposed.
  • The final rule still uses a maximum regional cost blending percentage of 50%, but finalizes a more gradual phase-in of the maximum blending percentage from the proposed rule for ACOs with historical expenditures above their regional service areas.
  • ACOs participating in the July to December 2019 performance period and selecting prospective assignment will be assigned beneficiaries based on October 2017 to September 2018 experience data.

Champagne, Mills and Karcher conclude that “CMS introduced the MSSP with the goal of transitioning ACOs to becoming risk-bearing entities and improving the quality of care provided to Medicare FFS beneficiaries. With the MSSP final rule, CMS has reaffirmed its commitment to these goals while offering greater shared savings potential to ACOs participating in the BASIC track and making the BASIC track available to a broader set of ACOs. The effect of these rule changes on specific ACOs will vary significantly depending on an ACO’s size, region, cost and quality performance, and structure.”

 

Fitch, Laurin and Berrios remind us that “one of the hallmarks of the new MSSP rule is faster movement to downside risk. Under the current regulations, accountable care organizations (ACOs) can stay in an upside-only track for up to six years. The new rule requires some ACOs in the Basic Track to begin assuming some downside risk in year 3.”  They stat that “under the new rule, there will be a more urgent need for ACOs to reduce population costs,” and that “two major tactics are typically implemented by health plans and ACOs to reduce population costs” are demand management and supply management.

 

Their report “focuses on supply management and, in particular, data mining tactics that identify medically unnecessary services.” They advocate "several data mining tactics we have seen successful ACOs adopt to effectively guide strategies to reduce medically unnecessary services and in turn reduce the ACO’s total population costs." including:

  • "For MSSP participants, the monthly Claim and Claim Line Feed (CCLF) data files provided by CMS should be routinely grouped and summarized into an actuarial cost model in order to evaluate cost drivers, identify potential targets for utilization reduction initiatives, track outcomes expected from key initiatives, and track overall costs compared to the ACO’s PMPY expenditure benchmark set by CMS."
  • "After identifying potential services to target from the actuarial cost model, organizations need to evaluate whether the utilization and spend in a service category represents efficient or inefficient care with very little or very large opportunity for improvement."
  • "ACOs must be able to target inefficient physician performance, which requires credible provider profiling. As with the benchmarking exercise described previously, physician profiling requires credible risk adjustment."
  • "ACO should also consider data mining to identify leakage of services to providers outside of the ACO." 
Friday
Jan042019

A Tour of 2019 Healthcare Predictions

By Clive Riddle, January 4, 2019 

We recently released our own 2019 healthcare prognostications, and now it’s time to take a tour of a selected healthcare weather forecasts for the year ahead, on a variety of fronts. 

First for a general overview, we stop at the PwC Health Research Institute’s 13th annual report on the year ahead, with six healthcare trends to watch in 2019

  1. Connected health devices and digital therapies will become integrated into care delivery and the regulatory process for drug and device approvals, with several new products coming to market
  2. Healthcare organizations will have to make major capital and training investments in artificial intelligence robotics, automation and data analytics in order to keep pace.
  3. The 2017 Tax Cuts and Jobs Act will continue to create tax savings for healthcare organizations while creating new challenges. 
  4. The healthcare industry is ready for a disruptor like Southwest, the budget airline provider was to that industry. 
  5. The pace of healthcare private equity investment will accelerate 
  6. Republican changes to the ACA will shift the law's winners and losers. Providers are on the losing end of most of these changes.

Also, providing an overall view is CareMore’s Sachin H. Jain in Forbes magazine with these: 10 Healthcare Industry Predictions for 2019:

  1. Humanism and humanity in healthcare will make a real comeback.
  2. The epidemic of loneliness will take center stage.
  3. Medicare Advantage will be seen as a template for the healthcare system of the future
  4. Quality measurement will focus on what happens in the exam room.
  5. The health care industry will make progress on new models for drug pricing.
  6. We will finally learn what Amazon, Berkshire Hathaway and JP Morgan are up to.
  7. Tech companies will get into the health care delivery business.
  8. More buzzwords: I’m not sure what language mashups we can expect next year, but rest assured they’ll generate plenty of conferences and spam emails.
  9. Another unlikely, head-scratching mega-merger will occur.
  10. We will all keep our new year’s resolutions: Each of us will lose fifteen pounds. We will all read a book a week. We’ll learn Mandarin, remember to call our grandparents, wash the dog more often and write that mystery novel about the doctor who uncovers a crime syndicate operating out of the hospital cafeteria 

One more overview entry on the tour comes from the 2019 HCEG Top 10 by the Healthcare Executive Group 

  1. Data & Analytics: Leveraging data (especially clinical) to manage health and drive individual, provider and payer decisions.
  2. Total Consumer Health: Improving members’ overall medical, social, financial, and environmental well-being.
  3. Population Health Services: Operationalizing community-based health strategy, chronic care management, driving clinical integration, and addressing barriers to health such as social determinants.
  4. Value-based Payments: Transitioning to and targeting specific medical conditions to manage cost and improve quality of care.
  5. The Digital Healthcare Organization: HSAs, portals, patient literacy, cost transparency, digital payments, CRM, wearables and other patient-generated data, health monitoring, and omni-channel access/distribution.
  6. Rising Pharmacy Costs: Implementing strategies to address growth of pharma costs along with benefits to quality of care and to total healthcare costs.
  7. External Market Disruption: New players like Amazon, Chase, Apple, Walmart, and Google.
  8. Operational Effectiveness: Implementing lean quality programs, process efficiency (with new core business models), robotics automation, revenue cycle management, real-time/near-time point of sales transactions, etc.
  9. Opioid Management: Developing strategies for identifying and supporting individuals and populations struggling with substance abuse/addiction or at risk of addiction.
  10. Cybersecurity: Protecting the privacy and security of consumer information to maintain consumer trust in sharing data 

Here’s a venture capital perspective on the healthcare industry from Venrock, featured in Fortune magazine: 10 Health Care Predictions for 2019 From a Pair of Venture Gurus 

  1. More payer consolidation
  2. Physician-led Accountable Care Organizations will grow rapidly
  3. Doctors get less dissatisfied
  4. Interoperability becomes interoperable: Five years after being declared successful, forces will finally come together to lead breakthroughs on cross health system and platform interoperability. 
  5. Consolidation in digital health
  6. We think that we are near peak hype cycle for insurance technology. 2019 is likely to be a year of toe stubbing for many. 
  7. Dialysis disrupted: Just as Sears has been replaced by home delivery, dialysis centers will be supplanted too. 
  8. Telemedicine takes off
  9. PBM disruption talk becomes reality
  10. Real progress with new DNA sequencing platforms 

Turning toward technology, CIO Magazine offers Healthcare technology markets: 5 predictions for 2019: 

  1. Health systems are investing in specific programs such as telehealth and remote monitoring. While these initiatives gather momentum, other digital health programs are struggling to emerge from pilot deployment and also face competing priorities for discretionary budgets.
  2. AI will make steady progress but will struggle with adoption gaps
  3. Big tech is yet to figure out its play for healthcare markets, with one possible exception (Apple Watch)
  4. Digital health startups will face a continuing struggle for growth and stability
  5. Blockchain will remain a solution looking for a problem 

On the policy front, Morning Consult offer thse Top 5 Health Policy Predictions for 2019

As cost of health care continues rising, states and industry set to act 

  1. Affordable Care Act: A ruling from a federal judge finding the Affordable Care Act unconstitutional has cast uncertainty on the future of the nation’s health care system — and reframed national debate on health reform ahead of the 2020 elections.
  2. CMS waiver guidance: Armed with a majority, House Democrats are poised to probe how the Trump administration has handled the ACA during the last two years
  3. Drug-pricing policy: Addressing the cost of prescription drugs is sure to continue dominating health priorities in 2019, although there is a long road from bipartisan commitment to reducing prices — to bipartisan consensus on how best to do so.
  4. Shift toward value-based payment structures: Increasing pressure on hospitals, which contributed to one-third of total health care spending last year, could drive a shift toward value-based payment models next year — a top priority in the Department of Health and Human Services’ Choice and Competition 2018 report.
  5. Digital therapeutics and e-health: After years of being just within reach, digital therapeutics and e-health initiatives stand to finally emerge in in the industry and transform care delivery next year. 

Next, we’ll consider employer benefit trends, with the selections of Mercer thought leader predictions posted here and here: 

  1. AI everywhere!  Healthcare will be the next industry to be transformed by AI. 
  2. Account-based plans create buzz.  
  3. Personalization of health care. 
  4. Value on investment: The new yardstick for benefits will be how they affect employees’ perception of their employer. 
  5. Transparency in Rx pricing.  
  6. Getting family-friendly fast. 
  7. Extreme claims get real.   A number of factors are driving an increase in both the prevalence and the size of extreme claims
  8. More stop loss. With the severity and frequency of catastrophic claims, employers will up their stop loss insurance levels and those that don’t buy it now will reconsider. 
  9. More outsourcing.  HR and health and wellbeing functions will increasingly be outsourced t
  10. Midsized employers doing something really different.  While jumbo employers are typically the trailblazers, this year midsized employers will take the lead with a couple of truly radical benefit strategies:
  11. Moderate cost growth allows longer-term focus. 
  12. Big things for behavioral health Change is happening in the behavioral health care delivery system.
  13. Specialty drugs will command attention. 
  14. Rx management gets yet more complicated. PBMs, carriers, pharma companies, and wholesalers will continue to face intense scrutiny regarding profits, delivery models and alignment (or lack of alignment) with plan sponsor goals.
  15. Employers mix it up with clinical services. 
  16. The issue of bill coding will surface. As doctors and hospitals become health systems, they are hiring coding experts at an increasingly rapid rate as a means of maximizing reimbursements. 

Finally, let’s end the tour peeking into pharmaceuticals, as CFO magazine features Deloitte’s Greg Reh in Four Trends That Could Shape Life Sciences in 2019 

  1. Greater scrutiny over drug pricing. 2018 was one of the biggest years for policy efforts to reduce drug prices and out-of-pocket expenses for patients. 
  2. Increased interest in contracts that demonstrate value. The launch of several gene and cell therapies has been a catalyst to advance the discussion of alternative payment models. 
  3. The declining return on investment for R&D. A Deloitte analysis on the ROI of R&D among 12 large-cap biopharma companies portrays a steep decline over the nine years that the analysis has been performed.
  4. Evolving regulatory frameworks and collaboration between industry and regulators. The U.S. Food and Drug Administration’s (FDA) pre-certification program, which launched in late 2017, is an example of how collaboration between industry and regulators can drive more self-regulation that is rooted in a culture of quality, organizational excellence, and performance monitoring. 

 

Friday
Dec142018

Nine Healthcare Business Trends for 2019

By Clive Riddle, December 14, 2018 

Here’s nine trends to keep a close watch on as we stand on the precipice of 2019:

1. The Year of SDOH

Health Plans, Health Systems and Public Agencies all will invest more heavily in Social Determinants of Health initiatives for their at risk populations. The number, scope, and resources involved in programs will significantly escalate, using a wide range of approaches. Some will be touted as quite successful, some will be deemed as failures, many will need much more time before conclusions can be drawn.

2. Continued Uptick in Uninsured

The Commonwealth Fund cites “The uninsured rates among lower-income adults rose from 20.9 percent in 2016 to 25.7 percent in March 2018.” The news won’t get better in 2019. The ongoing federal chipping away at the ACA in various forms will continue to yield a rising rate in the uninsured.

3. Much Ado About Prescriptions

PBMs, Specialty Drugs, and Pharmaceutical price hikes have been everyone’s punching bag. And the punching will continue with much noise in 2019. But what further policy changes might one expect out of Washington with the current climate? And just released National Health Expenditure data indicates “per capita prescription drug spending slightly decreased (down 0.3%) for the first time since 2012.” While Rx costs are projected to be troublesome in the coming years, the current stall in costs will likely stall momentum for actual change.

4. Amazon and CVS Will Be Busy Bees

CVS and Aetna are now out of the gate, and have already put forth transformational plans.Amazon isn’t just positioning for the pharmacy arena – they’re into healthcare tech and much more, let alone their venture with their employer driven triumvirate with Berkshire and JP Morgan.

5. Increased Focus on Million Dollar+ Claims

Even though general healthcare costs are increasing in the lower single digits, the real high end is not finding a ceiling. Million-dollar+ medical claims increase 87 percent from 2014-2017. Technological and clinical advances will keep pushing this forward, and an increasing amount of attention will be paid on how to deal with the highest end claims. 

6. EHR: Physician Pushback and Response

A Medical Economics magazine article this month starts off with: “It’s no secret that dissatisfaction with EHR systems has been a major concern for physicians. In fact, several recent surveys report as much as a 25 to 30 percent unhappiness level among doctors and practices.”  The pushback will not subside in 2019, and vendors have a major opportunity to promote how they can make physician’s work lives easier, if they truly can come up with some innovative responses. 

7. Employee Cost Sharing: Large Group and Small Group In Different Directions

The Commonwealth Fund reported this month that “premium and deductible costs amounted to nearly 12 percent of median income in 2017. Added together, the total cost of premiums to workers and potential spending on deductibles for both single and family policies climbed to $7,240 a year in 2017.” While e cost sharing in its many forms just continues to exact a growing burden on employees, large groups are shifting strategies away from increased cost sharing, while the small group market may see no respite in 2019. 

8. Cybersecurity Stakes Rise as Healthcare Data Breaches Continue

Its not very risk to predict high risk of more major healthcare data breaches in 2019. Healthcare cybersecurity investments will continue to grow in 2019.

9. Value Based Healthcare is Everywhere

The challenge in 2019: to find a healthcare organization that doesn’t have the words value-based emblazoned throughout its communications.

Friday
Dec072018

Premium and Deductible Cost Sharing: A Dozen Key Findings from the Commonwealth Fund

by Clive Riddle, December 7, 2018 

CMS has just touted the National Health Expenditure growth of 3.9% for 2017 is at historic low levels, with the Office of the Actuary stating “prior to the coverage expansions and temporary high growth in prescription drug spending during that same period, health spending was growing at historically low rates. In 2017, health care spending growth returned to these lower rates and the health spending share of GDP stabilized for the first time since 2013.” 

Meanwhile, The Commonwealth Fund paints a different picture from another perspective, and has just released a 21-page DataBrief: The Cost of Employer Insurance Is a Growing Burden for Middle Income Families, with lead author Sara Collins commenting “The cost of employer health insurance premiums and deductibles continues to outpace growth in workers’ wages. This is concerning, because it may put both coverage and health care out of reach for people who need it most — people with low incomes and those with health problems. Policies that would reduce health care burdens on employees include fixing the Affordable Care Act’s family coverage glitch, requiring employers to exclude some services from the deductible, and increasing the required minimum value of employer plans.” 

The Commonwealth Fund tells us their study uses “the latest data from the federal Medical Expenditure Panel Survey–Insurance Component (MEPS–IC) to examine trends in employer premiums at the state level to see how much workers and their families are paying for their employer coverage in terms of premium contributions and deductibles. We examine the size of these costs relative to income for those at the midrange of income distribution.” 

Here’s a dozen key findings: 

  1. Average employee premium contributions for single and family plans amounted to nearly 7 percent of U.S. median income in 2017, up from 5 percent in 2008. 
  2. In 11 states (Arizona, Delaware, Florida, Georgia, Louisiana, Mississippi, Nevada, New Mexico, North Carolina, Oklahoma, Texas), premium contributions were 8 percent of median income or more, with a high of 10.2 percent in Louisiana.
  3. Premium and deductible costs amounted to nearly 12 percent of median income in 2017. Added together, the total cost of premiums to workers and potential spending on deductibles for both single and family policies climbed to $7,240 a year in 2017. 
  4. This combined cost ranged from a low of $4,664 in Hawaii to a high of more than $8,000 in eight states (Alaska, Arizona, Delaware, New Hampshire, North Carolina, South Dakota, Texas, Virginia). 
  5. In two states, Mississippi and Louisiana, these combined costs rose to 15 percent or more of median income.
  6. Premiums for employer health plans rose sharply in nearly every state in 2017. After climbing modestly between 2011 and 2016, overall premiums for employer health plans (employer and employee share) grew more sharply in 2017, by 4.4 percent for single plans and 5.5 percent for family plans. 
  7. Annual single person premiums rose above $7,000 in eight states (Alaska, Connecticut, Delaware, Massachusetts, New Jersey, New York, Rhode Island, Wyoming) and family premiums were $20,000 or higher in seven states (Alaska, Connecticut, Massachusetts, New Jersey, New York, West Virginia, Wyoming) and the District of Columbia. 
  8. Average premiums for families increased overall in 44 states and the District of Columbia.
  9. As employer premiums have risen, so have workers’ contributions. Between 2016 and 2017, employee premium contributions rose by 6.8 percent to $1,415 for single-person plans and by 5.3 percent to $5,218 for family plans.
  10. Contributions for single plans increased in 32 states, ranging from a low of $675 in Hawaii to a high of $1,747 in Massachusetts. 
  11. Contributions for family plans rose in 35 states and the District of Columbia, with the lowest increase in Michigan ($3,646) and the highest in Delaware ($6,533).
  12. The average deductible for single policies rose to $1,808 in 2017, a 6.6 percent increase. Average deductibles rose in 35 states and the District of Columbia, ranging from a low of $863 in Hawaii to a high of about $2,300 in Maine and New Hampshire.

 

Friday
Nov302018

EHR and Patient Self-Pay: A Tale of Two Provider Woes

By Clive Riddle, November 30, 2018

In the provider administrative world, two continuing challenges causing large audible sighs are dealing with EHRs and ever-increasing levels of patient cost-sharing. An 11-page report just released on the annual HFMA/Navigant survey tackles these topics, providing findings from responses of 107 hospital and health system CFOs and revenue cycle management executives.

On the EHR front, we are told that 56% of executives “said their organizations can’t keep up with EHR upgrades or underuse available EHR functions, up from 51% last year. Moreover, 56% of executives suggested EHR adoption challenges have been equal to or outweighed benefits specific to their organization’s revenue cycle performance.”

Timothy Kinney, managing director at Navigant, says “hospitals and health systems have invested a significant amount of time and money into their EHRs, but the technology’s complexity is preventing them from realizing an immediate return on their investments.”

The survey found that 44% quickly adapt to EHR functional release, and the above cited 56% includes 39% that underutilize available EHR functions, and 17% can’t keep up with EHR functions. Regarding adoption challenges and benefits, the also above cited 56% includes 34% stating benefits and challenges are equal, and 22% who feel challenges outweigh benefits.

Regarding patient self-pay, the report tells us that 81% of executives “believe the increase in consumer responsibility for costs will continue to affect their organizations, down from 92% last year. Among them, 22% think that impact will be significant, compared to 40% last year. Executives from health systems and larger hospitals believe their organizations will be more heavily impacted by consumer self-pay.”

Navigant Managing Director James McHugh comments that “the impact of consumer self-pay on providers will only increase with the popularity of high-deductible health plans and negative changes to the economy. Providers must take advantage of opportunities to more holistically educate patients on out-of-pocket costs, predict their propensity to pay as early as possible, and secure alternative payers or financing when needed.”

The survey results seem to indicate self-pay continues to be a big issue, yet is more manageable now than a year ago. Time will tell if that trend continues.